Somehow my proposition goes up against the first and you will basic institution of relationships, however, in the event we are in favor of matrimony, as it is suitable of males whom build laws for all of us, we need to calmly consider man’s correct situation. Taking into consideration one to law comes out-of truth, this type of boys has united right here to write a constitution and therefore wipes clean the new errors of history and you can seeks a unique road for future years, [thus] it is important that they judiciously data the brand new criteria of your landscaping and you can started to the finish there exists some thing when you look at the our life and also in our world that we can’t during the in whatever way romantic all of our attention, that people need to deal with valiantly. 51
Hernandez reasoned one simple court sanction of an intimate commitment you will never be the actual only real evidence that a person are a real and you may moral resident
I have visited the fresh Installation to meagerly protect, on the good my element, this new Cuban lady, the brand new hitched girl, the latest single girl, the new light woman, brand new black girl, people of the many kinds. I want to point out that there are a great number of Cuban ladies in tough and you may awkward facts, who happen to be given that honorable and as worthy of merit since are most other females, that just as she actually is inside the a free commitment, does not always mean we should consider her along with her family relations immoral. 52
Because of the saying that an excellent disjuncture existed ranging from legislators’ ideals and “personal facts,” Hernandez argued one she was assaulting having Cubans who have been perhaps not aren’t considered models of intimate propriety and you will, hence, was unjustly disenfranchised
Twenty-a couple of out from the 60-half dozen Installation people gonna this new lesson chosen so you can agree Hernandez’s proposition. Most of people who chosen inside the like reasoned which would oblige guys inside the consensual unions to satisfy a similar hookup bars near me Lubbock commitments and you may requirements one to partnered men was indeed destined to satisfy and, for this reason, create cover every woman and children. Instance, progressive Installation user Capablanca debated you to definitely “though it [Hernandez’s amendment] appears paradoxical, from are…a strike toward matrimony, it really is a protection of it.” 53 He said, “When people know that he is guilty of female that have who he has an effective consensual partnership and for the students you to definitely impact from these 100 % free unions, chances are they doesn’t take part in consensual unions however in marriage.” 54 Capablanca represented men because the almost naturally irresponsible, and you can designed that ladies needed State defense against them. Anybody else echoed their rationale.
Although not, many Assembly participants, progressives and you can traditionals, balked at the Hernandez’s tip, arguing it was maybe not conducive so you’re able to popular advances and you will perform grant liberties and you may privileges so you can undeserving, immoral residents. Old-fashioned Installation user Cortina provided good spirited fight facing Hernandez’s proposition, framing their dissent while the a battle to have modernity, advances, and society. He asserted that an excellent constitutional ensure to adopt consensual unions comparable to help you court marriage ceremonies manage basically send Cuba out-of into the an appropriate street divergent from compared to “all of the civilized countries on the planet” and you will “ruin…the fresh new matrimonial system, to make [it] completely inadequate.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “Whether or not it amendment was in fact accepted, we possibly may make a massive confusion from inside the court marriage, and then we carry out make the consequences of one’s political revolution and that i have only existed through, so you can circles of our own psychological and family relations lifestyle, [sectors] and therefore won’t need to getting turned from the revolutionary and you will perturbing way that was recommended.” 56 Having Cortina, the fresh 1933 revolution is actually a political wave, and you may after that reform would be to merely apply at politics: Personal things shall be remaining by yourself.